Is The Market Underpricing Caterpillar Stock?

Nov 11, 2026
is-the-market-underpricing-caterpillar-stock?

Image from Pixabay

For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.

Caterpillar (CAT) shares lost 35.1%, counting dividends, in the six months to November 9, 2026, while the S&P 500 gained 2.4%. Following that decline, you pay 23.2 times the company’s earnings over the last twelve months, which sits close to the 23.3 average of its readings at the last twelve quarter-ends. Sales are growing again, however. What would the shares be worth if Caterpillar keeps growing its sales for three more years?

What Caterpillar Shares Could Be Worth In Three Years

Based on the assumptions below, Caterpillar shares would be worth about 60.8% more three years from now than at the November 9 close. To build this estimate, Trefis grew today’s revenue each year at 0.85 times its latest twelve-month pace and held the P/E at today’s level. The scenario sets the net margin three years out by taking 70% of today’s figure and adding 30% of its average from the previous twelve quarter-ends.

Here is how today’s figures compare with the scenario’s three years out.

All of that gain comes from higher revenue; the net margin barely changes, so it trims the upside only slightly. None of it comes from a higher P/E, so on these assumptions the market would be underpricing Caterpillar only if the company keeps selling more.

In fiscal 2025, most of Caterpillar’s revenue growth came from Power & Energy, a division that makes large reciprocating engines and turbines. Revenue in that segment rose to $32.2 billion from $28.9 billion, while Construction Industries and Resource Industries were roughly flat. Growth broadened in the third quarter of fiscal 2026, when Construction Industries grew sales 18%, climbing as fast as Power & Energy, whose segment sales also rose 18%.

Can Caterpillar Keep Its Sales Growing This Fast?

Caterpillar has the orders, and management says adding capacity is the main limit on growth in Power & Energy. Backlog reached a record $78 billion in the third quarter of fiscal 2026, up 96% from a year earlier. In power generation, sales to users rose 75% that quarter on demand for turbines and engines used in data centers, management said. That is a retail measure, on which all of Power & Energy grew 36%.

To meet that demand, Caterpillar plans to nearly triple its large reciprocating engine capacity from the 2024 level by 2030. Management’s outlook for fiscal 2026 sales growth in the mid- to high teens covers a year that is already three-quarters reported. The forecast therefore mostly reflects results already reported rather than a pace for later years.

Leave a comment