Volatile share prices create opportunities. But the market rarely sends a stock down for no reason, so how do investors tell a bargain from a trap?
When the market reacts to short-term issues with a move that implies long-term challenges, opportunities present themselves. Here’s how I go about looking for them.
Volatility
Greggs is a good example of a stock that’s been volatile recently. It’s fallen to £14.07 from just over £24 in less than a year.
That’s a swing of more than 70%, but the business hasn’t changed that much – or anything close. So why’s the stock market been treating it so differently?
The answer is that the firm’s like-for-like sales growth has gone from 2.1% to 3.4%. And while that doesn’t sound like much, it’s a big deal in terms of the company’s intrinsic value.
A discounted cash flow (DCF) model combines three things:
-
Near-term growth.
-
Long-term growth.
-
A discount rate.
Take a company earning 10p per share, growing at 7% for 10 years, then 4% forever, with a 9% discount rate. A DCF analysis suggests the present value of the stock is 263p.
The calculation has three inputs. But they don’t all have the same impact on the current value of the stock.
Reducing next year’s growth from 7% to zero takes 6.5% off the present value. But reducing the long-term growth rate from 4% to 2% knocks off nearly 20%.
That’s why Greggs jumped around 8% in a day when third-quarter like-for-like growth reached 3.4%. The market was reacting to a change in one of the best indicators of the long-term growth outlook.
Big declines imply long-term changes, but they often follow short-term news, like a soft quarter, cautious guidance, or an analyst downgrade. And that’s where I look for opportunities.
Ryanair: an undervalued opportunity?
Ryanair (NASDAQ:RYAA.Y) shares are down about 21% this year. That’s the kind of decline that should mean lasting damage, but the latest reports suggest it’s something much more like a difficult few months.
The main threat is oil. Ryanair is hedged pretty well into the end of the year, but after that costs are set to rise unless jet fuel prices come down – and that’s why investors are concerned.
A 21% decline in the share price however, makes it look permanent. And I’m wary of that assumption when oil prices are higher as a result of conflicts in the Middle East and Ukraine.
Even if these go on for longer, Ryanair has ways of bringing down costs. It has 16 Boeing 737 MAX 10s arriving in spring 2027, which should be significantly more efficient.